Do Salaried Workers Perform Better Than Piece Rate Workers?

| Publication date: 5 May 2010 | Theme: Employment & Social policy | NIESR Author(s): Bryson, A | External Author(s): Buriamo, B. and Simmons, R. | JEL Classification: J33; M52 | Report to: Aalto University, helsinki

Empirical evidence links switches to performance-related pay with improved worker performance. But pure piece rate working is uncommon. The majority of workers are salaried. We exploit a natural experiment in which some workers in a particular occupation (football referees) switch from pure piece rate to salaried annual contracts. We use this to establish the effects on worker performance. Worker performance improves among those who move onto salaried contracts relative to those who do not. The finding is robust to the introduction of worker fixed effects indicating that it is not driven by better workers being awarded salary contracts. Nor is it sensitive to workers sorting into or out of the profession. Improved performance could arise from the additional effort workers exert due to career concerns, the higher income associated with career contracts (an efficiency wage effect) or improvements in worker quality arising from off-the-job training which accompanies the salaried contracts.

Keyword tags: 
incentives, piece rate, productivity, sports

Research programmes