- Home
- Publications
- Exploring The Short- And Long-Run Links From Bank Competition To Risk – Reconciling Conflicting Hypotheses?
Exploring the Short- and Long-Run Links from Bank Competition to Risk – Reconciling Conflicting Hypotheses?
Using a dataset for the EU-27 covering 1998-2012, this is one of the first studies of banking competition and risk to look at the dynamics of the relation between these variables, to take account of a full 6 year period since the onset of the crisis in 2007, as well as a comparable period before it; and to compare and contrast results using two competition indicators, the H statistic and the Lerner index. Using the H statistics, we find that in the crucial pre crisis period, the change in competition has a positive effect on risk (measured by the Z Score), while there is a overall negative effect of the level of competition on risk. The Lerner index provides results supportive of the hypothesis that there are dynamic relations between competition and risk, in that the change in the Lerner index again correlates positively with risk (i.e. narrower margins when competition increases make banks weaker) while the long run effect of heightened competition is also to increase risk. Testing for the reason for differences in long run effects we find that the H and Lerner differ in their impact on the volatility of profits, a key input to the Z Score risk indicator. There are important implications for the interpretation of results in the literature based on these different indicators.
Related Blog Posts
Public Debt Sustainability and Fiscal Rules
Stephen Millard
Benjamin Caswell
05 Feb 2024
4 min read
UK Investment Past and Prospects: A Framework for Analysis
Catherine Mann
01 Dec 2023
6 min read
Related Projects
Related News
Call for Papers: Lessons From Quantitative Easing & Quantitative Tightening
09 Feb 2024
1 min read
Related Publications
The Nature of the Inflationary Surprise in Europe and the USA
21 Mar 2024
Discussion Papers
Energy and Climate Policy in a DSGE Model of the United Kingdom
08 Mar 2024
Discussion Papers
Exploring Alternative Data Sources for Household Wealth Statistics
24 Jan 2024
Discussion Papers
Inflation Differentials Among European Monetary Union Countries: An Empirical Evaluation With Structural Breaks
20 Nov 2023
National Institute Economic Review